Archive · How the crater was studied

Reading Molokini’s 1930 field survey

A geologist’s map, ship soundings and a botanist’s specimen list reveal both the value and the limits of an early scientific portrait.

Friends of Molokini · Source-based reference2 min readSource check: November 18, 2026

A small paper with a large view

Harold S. Palmer’s Geology of Molokini, published by Bishop Museum in 1930, is paired with Edward L. Caum’s Notes on the Flora of Molokini. The paper combines a description of the crescent, a topographic map, rock observations, a proposed geological history and a botanical compilation. It is a particularly useful archive because the authors explain how much of their picture was assembled.

Palmer carried out mapping and geological work during an October 1925 visit, with assistance connected to the United States Lighthouse Service. He describes using a plane table and telescopic alidade to locate survey points. For inaccessible outer slopes, photographs taken around the island helped supply observations that could not be obtained by walking the cliffs.

The seabed came partly from an earlier ship

The underwater contours drew on soundings from the Coast and Geodetic Survey vessel Patterson in 1904, obtained through a Lighthouse Service blueprint. Palmer cautioned that the available soundings were limited and that the submarine contours were only moderately accurate. Those cautions are part of the evidence, not inconveniences to omit when displaying an attractive old map.

A historical chart can reveal what researchers understood at the time. It cannot automatically serve as a modern navigation chart or a precise model for positioning a boat, diver or camera feature. The appropriate use here is comparison and explanation, with its date and method shown.

An apparent smoke plume in 1819

Palmer also revisited an earlier travel account by Jacques Arago, who described a column of apparent smoke above Molokini on August 15, 1819. Arago’s pilots reportedly rejected the suggestion that a volcano was erupting there. Palmer searched for relatively recent volcanic rock during his own work and reported finding none. He proposed windblown dust as a possible explanation for the earlier appearance.

The observation and the later attempt to test it are both part of the historical record. Palmer’s investigation did not establish an eruption in 1819; his proposed dust explanation remained an interpretation of the earlier account.

Measurements need their original context

Palmer reported an area of 18.9 acres and a maximum elevation of 165 feet above mean lower low tide. Present-day DOFAW summaries use approximately 22 acres and 160 feet. Different measurement methods, boundaries, rounding and vertical references can produce differences; the figures alone do not measure how much the island has grown or shrunk.

The flora is a historical baseline

Caum brought together collections by Charles N. Forbes in 1913 and Palmer in 1925, reporting 21 plant species between the two surveys. The accompanying discussion records differences in collection and identification, giving a useful glimpse of scientific work in progress. A plant list from those visits is a dated record rather than proof that every listed taxon is present today.

The publication also contains landing and walking advice from its era. Modern visitors should follow the sanctuary’s current access restrictions instead. The scientific descriptions are valuable precisely when their age, methods and limits remain visible.

Sources & further reading

Browse the full source notes for publication details, page references and limitations.

Follow the connections

geology

How Molokini formed

The crescent is the exposed part of a volcanic tuff cone on Haleakalā’s submerged flank. Its age is an estimate with published uncertainty.

2 min read · Sources included
history

One crater, two kinds of protection

The seabird island and the surrounding marine district are connected ecologically but have different boundaries, responsibilities and access rules.

2 min read · Sources included
history

Molokini’s wartime legacy and the ordnance decisions

Official records document WWII-era munitions and a change from proposed remediation to a 2020 decision to leave two identified items in place.

2 min read · Sources included

See a correction or have a stronger local record? Send the source and the page address.

Contact Friends of Molokini