A change in people, followed by a change in fish
Weng and colleagues combined underwater fish surveys, commercial visitor records and acoustic telemetry around the 2020 tourism shutdown and reopening. They observed more fish biomass during the early shutdown and changes in how bluefin trevally used the inner crater. As visitation returned, the earlier pattern of avoidance during busy periods reappeared.
The increase happened too quickly to interpret as a new generation of fish growing to adult size. Movement into surveyed habitat is a central explanation. Fish biomass in a transect can increase because fish relocate; it does not automatically mean that the total population across the wider ocean has grown.
A marine reserve still needs visitor management
The study’s practical lesson is that non-extractive recreation can affect habitat use inside a protected area. Removing fish is not the only way people can alter a reef community. A reserve can prohibit most fishing while still experiencing disturbance from intense visitation.
This was a real-world natural experiment, not a randomized test of one boat, engine design or operator. Tourism, swimmers and vessel activity changed together. The paper cannot assign an exact share of the response to engine noise alone, and it is not a ranking of commercial businesses.
What a historical comparison can tell us
Historical comparisons depend on observation dates and survey methods. Fish biomass is a biological survey estimate; visitation is an operational count. A webcam alone cannot measure reef recovery. Paired time series could test whether quieter periods coincide with changes in fish detections, but a correlation would not by itself establish the cause.
Friends of Molokini proposes documenting vessel-hours, underwater sound and repeat biological surveys together. Publishing methods and missing periods would let a future reader distinguish a measured change from a persuasive-looking graphic.
Sources & further reading
- Decreased tourism during the COVID-19 pandemic positively affects reef fish in a high use marine protected area — Weng, Friedlander, Gajdzik, Goodell & Sparks / PLOS ONE, 2023.
Browse the full source notes for publication details, page references and limitations.
