More than one account
Molokini does not have a single recorded origin story. The Fornander collection preserves an account of Puʻuoinaina and Pele, another of Kana breaking Hāʻupu, and a separate story in which Molokini is the wife of Puʻulaina. Elsewhere in the collection, Molokini is connected to the birth of Kahoʻolawe. These are distinct narratives, with different relationships and events. Combining their characters into one seamless tale would erase information that the sources preserve.
The individual pages in this collection retell particular published versions. They are introductions to reading, not substitutes for the Hawaiian text, for other family or community versions, or for the knowledge of practitioners. A twentieth-century publication date dates the printed record; it does not date the events within a moʻolelo.
Follow the place connections
The stories connect the crater to a much wider geography. Puʻuoinaina links Kahoʻolawe, Mākena and hills near Māʻalaea. Puʻulaina links Molokini to the mountains and hills of west Maui. Kana carries the narrative toward Molokaʻi and Hawaiʻi Island. The Kaipalaoa story places Molokini within an island-name exchange in a contest of words. A place can be important in a story even when the main action happens elsewhere.
For readers looking out from the camera, these connections offer a different kind of map: one organized by relationships and remembered names. That is an invitation to read carefully, not permission to turn every place into a visitor attraction or to enter protected land.
How these pages handle evidence
Each retelling identifies the publication used. When a source says who becomes which landform, the page retains that detail rather than silently replacing it with a popular version. Explanations supplied by this website are presented as reading notes, without invented dialogue, ceremonies or translations. We do not claim these pages have received Native Hawaiian community review.
Geology, historical documentation and moʻolelo appear together in the explorer but remain clearly labeled. A radiometric estimate asks when volcanic rock formed. A recorded genealogy expresses relationships among islands and people. Treating these as interchangeable claims would misunderstand both kinds of source. Contemporary discussion in the Office of Hawaiian Affairs’ Ka Wai Ola also draws attention to the diversity of Molokini’s narratives.
A note about the old books
The bilingual Fornander volumes preserve valuable material, while their English translations and editorial notes also contain the language and judgments of their publication era. Terms such as “lizard” in an old translation should not make a supernatural moʻo character equivalent to an ordinary animal in the wildlife atlas. The source’s title may use “myth” or “folk-lore”; our headings retain moʻolelo and identify the particular text being discussed.
Sources & further reading
- Myth Concerning Molokini, Fornander Collection, vol. V, pp. 514–521 — Bernice P. Bishop Museum; Abraham Fornander collection, edited by Thomas G. Thrum, 1919.
- Story of Puulaina, Fornander Collection, vol. V, pp. 532–536 — Bernice P. Bishop Museum; Abraham Fornander collection, edited by Thomas G. Thrum, 1919.
- Fornander Collection, vol. IV: traditions of the islands, Kahoʻolawe and Molokini — Bernice P. Bishop Museum; public-domain transcription by Project Gutenberg, 1916–1917.
- Legend of Kaipalaoa, the Hoopapa Youngster, Fornander Collection, vol. V, pp. 574–595 — Bernice P. Bishop Museum; Abraham Fornander collection, edited by Thomas G. Thrum, 1919.
- The Wahi Pana of Molokini — Ka Wai Ola, Office of Hawaiian Affairs, 2022.
- Volcano Watch: Molokini erupted about 230,000 years ago — U.S. Geological Survey, Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, 2001.
Browse the full source notes for publication details, page references and limitations.
